There are five keys to a good thesis, and a good thesis is the foundation of a good paper!

A good thesis should do four things:

  1. Take a stance
  2. Preview the paper’s argument
  3. Aim for brevity
  4. Be definitive
  5. So let’s tackle them one at a time.

The point of a real thesis is not to point out that there is a conflict, or that there are multiple solutions. The point of a real thesis is to choose a side of an issue, a method for problem solving, or a perspective for interpretation and prove that stance’s validity. Use your introduction to show your reader that there are multiple methods or viewpoints, if needed. And then use your thesis to stake out a position in that controversy and inform your reader what you’ll be arguing for.

I have seen – and sadly, written – many papers with the thesis “There are two sides to this issue, both have merits, and this paper will explore the merits of both and conclude that they both have strengths and witnesses, because I, the author, am too afraid of commitment to actually take a stance.” Maybe not in so many words, but that’s the gist of them. Unless this is your PhD thesis, it’s just a paper, not a manifesto for the rest of your life. So choose a side of the issue you know you can argue for, and make that clear in your thesis.

But I don’t mean in the terrible four square way. Did anyone else have to do four square writing as a kid? It was the bane of my elementary school existence, it looked like this:

We're college students. We've progressed past this dark time in our lives.Pin this image on Pinterest
We’re college students. We’ve progressed past this dark time in our lives.

And basically you had to put your main topic in the middle – for example, “social media” – and then in the squares around it, write a reason for or against it with some examples or evidence. Then the last square relisted your three reasons and added why they were important. Then, you used the foursquare to write your paper’s thesis, and it read like this:

“I think social media is good because it connects you to family, makes you read and write, and lets you read the news.”

Don’t think of your grown-up thesis the same way. Instead of using your thesis as a list of your arguments, you should consider it a one sentence summary of your paper’s argument. Something like:

“Social media helps society by reinforcing positive connections and behaviors in users’ leisure time.”

Isn’t that a better thesis? Your readers now know that they’re looking for connections and behaviors that are supposed to be good, without you having to list “family connections, reading, and news” already. Also, it sounds less like a third grader wrote it, but I did that on purpose. For contrast.

I know, I know, it’s me telling people to say fewer words, which is hypocritical. But hear me out. So many people try to do the two sentence thesis, but it’s almost never necessary. A good way to test this is to write a full intro paragraph with your two-sentence thesis embedded in. Then, without telling them it’s two sentences, ask a friend who’s not familiar with the topic to read it and pull out the thesis. If they only choose one sentence, your other sentence isn’t needed – work any essential points into the one they chose and move forward.

I say this not because I’m a crazy lady who hates two-sentence theses, but because readers – including whoever’s grading you – are looking for a one-sentence thesis to tell them what to expect in the paper. Anything not included in the sentence they think is the thesis will seem out of place later in the paper.

The word “might” should never appear in your thesis. Be direct and clear about the point you want to make, and don’t hedge or soften your statement. If you don’t feel strongly enough about your argument to put it in a declarative sentence, you should choose another paper topic. Aim for strong language that makes your support for your thesis entirely clear. Whether you’re establishing cause and effect, advocating for a solution, or interpreting something, you need to be your argument’s number one fan, and that relies on you using clear and definitive language.

Giving your thesis a definitive starting phrase is a great way to establish your point of view.Pin this image on Pinterest
Giving your thesis a definitive starting phrase is a great way to establish your point of view.

And that’s flexible. The thesis you write during your outline, and refer back to during the essay-writing process, should support your ideas as you write them. But it’s also the main argument of a paper you haven’t finished yet, so your thesis isn’t finished until your paper is. We all have those moments where we’re writing something and have a stroke of sudden genius – the best idea in the world – and it changes the rest of our paper. That should should change your thesis, too.

A thesis is an argument, a claim, yeah, but it’s the reflection and distillation of every word you write after it, so your final editing process might mean changing your thesis a little – and that’s okay.

Of course, once you’ve adjusted your thesis, you’ll want to proofread your paper one more time to make sure everything still looks good. Fine-tuning your thesis is a great way to finish your paper-writing process and be sure you’ve covered all your bases and fulfilled your prompt’s requirements. What’s the hardest part of a thesis for you? How often does your thesis change while you write?

Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post